By Marcus Moloko
The Madlanga Commission’s chief evidence leader, Advocate Matthew Chaskalson, is expected to formally respond to a bid by North West businessman and alleged political fixer Brown Mogotsi to have him removed from the inquiry.
Mogotsi’s legal team filed the application late last month, accusing Chaskalson of bias, unfairness, and “bullying” during questioning.
ALSO READ: WATCH LIVE: Vusimusi Cat Matlala back in court with co accused as evidence battle resumes
They claim he branded Mogotsi a professional liar and pressured him to implicate another North West businessman and ANC member, Suliman Carrim.
Mogotsi’s testimony, which was postponed in March due to illness is now scheduled to resume in May, immediately after the commission hears the recusal application.
Chaskalson, regarded as one of the country’s most cerebral advocates and a formidable cross-examiner, has rejected the allegations outright, insisting he acted within his mandate as chief evidence leader.
He has previously accused Mogotsi of lying under oath and alluded to the recusal attempt being a tactic to derail the commission’s work.
Chaskalson is expected to make it clear that he will not step aside.
ALSO READ: Adams due in court Thursday as PKTT arrest and political tensions over case mount
Since his appointment in September 2025, Chaskalson has brought several facts to light to the commission. These include:
Evidence that 121 police dockets were removed and left inactive at SAPS headquarters to shield certain individuals.
WhatsApp messages and audio recordings showing alleged crime boss Vusimusi “Cat” Matlala purchased 20 impalas for the farm of suspended Deputy National Commissioner Shadrack Sibiya.
Testimony from Sergeant Fannie Nkosi, who admitted to using a criminal’s misplaced bank card for unauthorized cash withdrawals.
Chaskalson has indicated he will seek permission from professional bodies such as the Bar Council and Legal Practice Council before deposing to his affidavit, ensuring his reply meets strict ethical standards.
By placing himself under their oversight, he aims to demonstrate that his response is grounded in professional duty, not personal vendetta.
ALSO READ: Hawks boss links KZN provincial head to disappearance of 541kg cocaine
Commission spokesperson Jeremy Michaels confirmed that Chaskalson’s legal team will submit papers this afternoon.
The commission is expected to set Mogotsi’s new hearing date by 15 May, with the recusal matter heard that morning.
The outcome will determine whether Chaskalson continues leading evidence in one of the country’s most politically sensitive inquiries.
INSIDE POLITICS
