- Advertisement -spot_img

Judge Mfenyana says legal ethics goes beyond compliance with the law

- Advertisement -spot_img

Must read

By Charmaine Ndlela

Ethics in the legal profession goes beyond simply complying with the law, Judge Sandiswa Mfenyana has warned, saying legal practitioners must uphold professional responsibility even when legislation does not provide clear answers.

Mfenyana, of the North West Division of the High Court, was speaking at Rosebank International’s Faculty of Law 2026 Research Symposium on Tuesday.

The symposium, held at the institution’s Braamfontein campus under the theme “Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility in a Changing Legal Landscape”, brought together legal professionals, academics, researchers, students and industry stakeholders to discuss the changing legal environment.

Mfenyana said while the law generally sets minimum standards of conduct, ethical considerations should guide legal professionals when legislation does not provide clear answers.

“Ethics extends beyond mere compliance with legal requirements. The law generally establishes minimum standards of conduct, while ethical considerations may guide behaviour in circumstances where legislation does not provide a clear answer,” she said.

She said professional ethics was based on shared standards, values and responsibilities that members of the legal profession were expected to uphold.

“These standards are not dependent on the personal views or preferences of an individual practitioner; rather, they reflect the responsibilities and expectations attached to being a member of the profession,” Mfenyana said.

The symposium also examined the growing influence of artificial intelligence (AI) in the legal sector and the ethical questions arising from its use.

Associate Professor Michele Van Eck of the Wits School of Law at the University of the Witwatersrand cautioned against allowing AI to dominate discussions about the future of the legal profession.

Van Eck said technology could assist legal practitioners but could not take responsibility for decisions or outcomes.

“The machine (AI) answers for nothing,” she said.

“AI cannot ultimately be held accountable for the decisions it produces or assists with. AI can assist us, but it cannot replace human responsibility and judgement.”

She said the debate around AI also highlighted the need to address existing ethical challenges in decision-making and ensure that justice remained accessible to all.

Van Eck said maintaining a strong and ethical legal education system was a shared responsibility between academics and legal practitioners.

The symposium highlighted the need for legal professionals to adapt to a rapidly changing environment shaped by technological innovation, evolving societal expectations, socio-economic factors and emerging legal challenges.

Dr Rufaro Mavunga, Dean of the Faculty of Law at Rosebank International, said legal ethics could not be treated as something acquired through a single academic module.

She said ethical practice required continuous engagement and reflection as the legal profession evolved.

“Legal ethics is not something one suddenly acquires, neither is it a module encounter but it requires continual engagement and reflection. As the legal landscape changes, one needs to reflect,” Mavunga said.

She said the symposium was intended to create a platform for academics, legal professionals and students to engage critically with the responsibilities of the profession.

“The objective is to create a space for academics, legal professionals and students to share ideas, reflections on legal ethics and professional responsibilities,” Mavunga said.

The symposium forms part of Rosebank International’s broader focus on academic excellence, research and developing graduates equipped to contribute to the legal profession and wider society.

INSIDE POLITICS

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Inside Education E-edition August 2026

spot_img

Services Seta 2026

spot_img

CATHSSETTA

spot_img

AVBOB STEP 12

spot_img

Inside Metros G20 COJ Edition

spot_img

JOZI MY JOZI

spot_img

QCTO

spot_img

Latest article