- Advertisement -spot_img

ALPA takes impeachment evidence leader dispute to Constitutional Court

- Advertisement -spot_img

Must read

By Sihle Mavuso

The African Legal Practitioners Association (ALPA) has approached the Constitutional Court on an urgent basis to challenge last week’s Western Cape High Court judgment dismissing its application to have Advocate Thandazani Madonsela SC removed as evidence leader of the Impeachment Committee.

ALPA, which brought the application alongside the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), is seeking to overturn the High Court’s majority judgment in favour of a dissenting judgment by Judge James Lekhuleni.

Madonsela was removed by the Impeachment Committee on September 1, 2026, after President Cyril Ramaphosa, who is the subject of the now-stalled impeachment process, wrote to the committee on August 18 objecting to Madonsela leading the proceedings.

Ramaphosa argued that Madonsela had a conflict of interest because he had previously advised an ANC parliamentary study group on the matter.

However, ALPA argues that the majority judgment by Judges Fortuin and Van Zyl effectively grants Ramaphosa veto powers that are not provided for in the Constitution.

The association wants the Constitutional Court to uphold Lekhuleni’s dissenting judgment, which it considers the correct interpretation of the law and the evidence before the High Court.

ALPA argues that the majority judgment misdirected itself by focusing on whether the Impeachment Committee could treat a formal declaration by the ANC as new information that had not previously been before it.

It says the central question was whether any new facts had emerged and argues that, on the undisputed evidence, none had.

“The Committee acted for an ulterior purpose, in bad faith and under dictation. It reversed its decision because the President objected and in order to avoid his litigation, as its members said, and its purpose was to assist him in delaying the enquiry. The majority does not refer to a single one of those statements,” ALPA’s legal team argued in court papers filed on November 16.

The association said the dissenting judgment dealt with each of these issues by examining the evidence on record, while the majority judgment failed to address them adequately.

“The dissent dealt with each of these issues head on, and decided each of them on the record, whereas the majority did not. I respectfully submit that the dissent is correct, and that the majority’s judgment is unsustainable on the facts and the law.

“It is this Court, as the apex court, which must have the last say on whether a committee of Parliament may so abuse its power in the discharge of its constitutional duty to hold the President to account,” the legal team submitted.

ALPA has also asked the Constitutional Court to hear the matter urgently, warning that the Impeachment Committee had postponed appointing another evidence leader only until the High Court delivered its judgment.

It argues that the committee is now free to proceed with the appointment and that, if it does so before the Constitutional Court determines the matter, the relief sought could become ineffective.

Alternatively, ALPA warned that appointing a new evidence leader could cause further disruption if that appointment later had to be reversed.

In its papers, the association’s legal representative described the committee’s decision on September 1 as a serious abuse of public power, alleging that members who voted to reverse the earlier decision acted in bad faith and for an ulterior purpose.

“I am advised and respectfully submit that what occurred on 1 September 2026 was not merely irrational. It was a serious abuse of public power by the members who voted for rescission, for an ulterior purpose and in bad faith. I do not make that submission lightly. It is founded on the Committee’s own transcripts, minutes and correspondence, and I deal with the evidence under the fifth ground below,” the representative said.

INSIDE POLITICS

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Inside Education E-edition August 2026

spot_img

Services Seta 2026

spot_img

CATHSSETTA

spot_img

AVBOB STEP 12

spot_img

Inside Metros G20 COJ Edition

spot_img

JOZI MY JOZI

spot_img

QCTO

spot_img

Latest article