By Thapelo Molefe
Sector Education and Training Authorities (SETAs) are losing millions of rands through poorly managed training contracts, abandoned projects and payments to service providers who fail to deliver.
The Auditor-General of South Africa (AGSA) has warned that weaknesses in the way SETAs plan, allocate and monitor funding are allowing money to be spent without learners completing their training or obtaining the qualifications they were promised.
Briefing the Select Committee on Education, Sciences and Creative Industries on Tuesday, the AGSA’s senior audit manager, Bulelwa Mbangwa-Sikweyiya, said the problems extended across the entire skills development funding chain, from identifying training needs to appointing service providers and monitoring projects.
She said some contracts were structured in ways that left SETAs exposed to financial losses, including arrangements that allowed service providers to receive substantial payments before any training had taken place.
Deputy Business Unit Leader at AGSA, Zamahlangu Mditshwa, said some service providers received up to 50% of contract amounts upfront, leaving SETAs vulnerable when contractors failed to complete their obligations.
“If you are paying to an extent of even up to 50% of the contract amount without any intervention having taken place, that leaves the SETAs vulnerable,” Mditshwa said.
“There’s a need for them to relook at how they are structuring their contracts and their processes to ensure that there is protection of the funding that has been allocated to the SETAs.”
She said the ultimate expectation should be that money paid to service providers results in learners obtaining the qualifications they were meant to receive.
“The ultimate goal is that the student is going to get the full benefit up to the qualification that would have been envisioned when the contract would have been signed,” Mditshwa said.
The AGSA found that the higher education and post-school education and training portfolio was sitting with approximately R2 billion in accumulated irregular expenditure and R536 million in fruitless and wasteful expenditure from previous years.
The irregular expenditure was linked largely to non-compliance with supply chain management requirements and SETA grant regulations. The AGSA found cases where discretionary grants were awarded without following fair processes, as well as instances where entities did not comply with rules governing administrative costs.
Services SETA, Construction SETA, Health and Welfare SETA (HWSETA), SAQA and LGSETA were identified among the contributors to irregular expenditure.
The AGSA also warned that fruitless and wasteful expenditure was increasing. Services SETA, LGSETA and HWSETA featured among the contributors, with the spending linked to payments for projects where learners were not eventually trained, abandoned projects and funds not used for their intended purposes.
Some of the fruitless and wasteful expenditure involved payments for projects where learners were never trained, abandoned projects and funding that was not used for its intended purpose.
The Auditor-General also raised concerns about material irregularities involving projects that were abandoned after payments had been made, information technology systems that were developed but never used, and buildings that were constructed or purchased but remained unused.
Mbangwa-Sikweyiya said the same institutions continued to feature among the major contributors to financial losses, including the Construction SETA, Services SETA, Manufacturing, Engineering and Related Services SETA (MERSETA) and Local Government SETA.
She warned that the continued appearance of the same entities across different audit findings pointed to deeper institutional problems rather than isolated accounting errors.
The AGSA further warned that outstanding assessments and investigations into irregular and fruitless expenditure were delaying consequence management. Entities are expected to complete the assessment and investigation of such cases within six months.
The audit also found that some SETAs were funding employees, beneficiaries and dependants of their own staff through discretionary grants. In some cases, the beneficiaries included learners in primary and high schools, raising concerns about whether the money was being used for its intended purpose.
Another concern was the gap between the number of learners enrolled in programmes and those expected to complete them.
Mbangwa-Sikweyiya said SETAs were often achieving their enrolment targets but failing to ensure that learners completed their programmes.
She said this undermined the purpose of skills development funding, particularly where learners entered programmes but left without the qualifications needed to participate in the economy.
The AGSA also found weaknesses in how SETAs identified training needs, with research often duplicated across institutions and insufficiently shared.
Workplace Skills Plans and tracer studies, which should help identify employer requirements and track learner outcomes, were also not being used effectively.
The audit further raised concerns about contract extensions becoming common practice, with limited consequences for employers who failed to complete training within agreed timelines.
Some payments were made based on documentation rather than tangible evidence that learners had received training.
The AGSA said SETAs were also exceeding the 10.5% administrative spending limit in some instances, meaning money intended for skills development was instead being used for administration.
Mbangwa-Sikweyiya recommended that Parliament require the Higher Education Department to provide a detailed implementation plan for the planned SETA reforms, alongside regular reports on governance improvements and the protection of public funds.
She also called for progress reports on the implementation of an integrated learner information system to address duplication in learner records and reporting across the sector.
The committee briefing was, however, adjourned before the department could respond to the findings after members raised concerns about the absence of Higher Education Minister Buti Manamela and Deputy Minister Nomusa Dube-Ncube.
Acting Director-General Nadia Starr told the committee that she had been in the position for 17 days following the end of former director-general Dr Nkosinathi Sishi’s term on 31 October.
Starr said the department was aware of the concerns raised by the Auditor-General and apologised for the absence of political leadership.
Committee chairperson Makhi Feni said the findings required political as well as administrative accountability and that the committee could not proceed with the engagement without the necessary leadership present.
The meeting was adjourned, with a further date to be communicated.
INSIDE POLITICS










