By Johnathan Paoli
Johannesburg Metro Police Department (JMPD) Chief Superintendent Emosacia Tintswalo Rikhotso came under intense scrutiny at the Madlanga Commission on Thursday, with commissioners accusing her of repeatedly lying to police investigators and the inquiry about her alleged involvement in an attempt to bribe investigating officers following the theft of R1.5 million.
Rikhotso, who admitted lying in a recording made by investigators, struggled to explain why she had repeatedly implicated herself and fellow JMPD officer Inspector Emma Phakoane in an alleged bribery scheme, despite claiming that she knew the account was untrue.
“You had a chance in 2026 to tell the truth when you met with the investigators of the commission. You did not. You simply repeated what you said in 2023. Why is that so?” co-commissioner Sandile Khumalo asked.
The case stems from the alleged theft of approximately R1.5 million from businessman Nawazish Ali Raja during a police operation in 2023.
Subsequent allegations suggested that JMPD officers and other individuals attempted to secure the release of arrested officer Eric Mphahlele and derail the investigation through an alleged R800,000 bribe to investigating officers.
The questioning centred on a handwritten statement Rikhotso made to the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (DPCI) in August 2023 and a subsequent recorded interview in which she described how money was allegedly collected and delivered in an attempt to secure the release of a JMPD officer arrested in connection with the theft.
Rikhotso maintained that Phakoane had instructed her on what to write in the statement, including details about collecting money from the arrested officer’s family.
However, when Khumalo played a recording in which she described collecting the money, despite previously denying knowledge of it, Rikhotso admitted that she had lied.
“So why do you in this clip say you collected the money from either the sister or the cousin?” Khumalo asked.
“I was telling them what I wrote on the statement,” Rikhotso responded.
“So you were lying in the clip?” Khumalo asked.
“Yes,” she conceded.
Asked why she had lied, Rikhotso said she was protecting Phakoane.
Khumalo challenged this explanation, pointing out that her account implicated Phakoane in collecting money allegedly intended to bribe police officers.
“It doesn’t make sense. Human beings don’t behave that way,” he said.
He questioned how Phakoane could have instructed her to include information that implicated herself in criminal activity.
Evidence leader Thabang Pooe subsequently confronted Rikhotso with the fact that she had repeated substantially the same version to the commission’s investigators in 2026, despite having an opportunity to correct the alleged falsehoods in her 2023 statement.
Rikhotso denied deliberately misleading investigators, maintaining that she had merely repeated what Phakoane instructed her to say.
However, Pooe pointed out that she had repeated the same account on several occasions, including when she did not have her handwritten statement in front of her.
Pooe also questioned what Rikhotso stood to gain from becoming so deeply involved in the matter, including attending meetings, making calls, allegedly collecting and delivering money, and subsequently approaching the DPCI.
Rikhotso said she had trusted Phakoane, with whom she had worked for approximately 20 years, and initially had no reason to suspect that her colleague’s requests were made in bad faith.
Pressed on why she had continued repeating the account years later, Rikhotso eventually said she had been frightened after learning that a syndicate was operating and that she could be killed if she changed her statement.
“I was scared of my life. I found out that this is a syndicate that involves a lot of people. I was told that Inspector Emma, she was one of the people in the syndicate. And there are a lot. They target people with money,” she said.
Rikhotso denied receiving money to lie or being part of the alleged scheme.
Commissioners also questioned why she had not reported the alleged syndicate to the JMPD chief, given her senior position and claims that it involved serving police officers and other stakeholders.
She said she had not reported it because she lacked evidence and there was already a pending case.
Asked to identify the other stakeholders, Rikhotso named members of the Hawks and informers who allegedly supplied information about businesspeople carrying cash.
She alleged that syndicate members used informers to establish when and where businesspeople would be travelling with money before stopping and robbing them.
The commission instructed her to submit a written list of the names of the Hawks members she believed were involved after she said she would only identify them off-camera.
Khumalo also questioned her account of the alleged R1.5 million robbery involving Raja, including whether she knew that more money had been stolen than initially reported.
Rikhotso denied knowing the amount.
Commissioners described her testimony as contradictory and lacking candour. One questioned whether she was herself part of the alleged syndicate, an allegation she denied.
Proceedings were adjourned for the day.
The commission will resume on Monday morning after the next witnesses were unavailable to testify on Friday.
INSIDE POLITICS










