By Zanoxolo Jozana
A Nigerian man who sought R5.4 million in damages from the police over his arrest and detention in a Durban murder investigation has failed in his latest attempt to challenge the dismissal of his claim.
Sunday Ikechukwu Okoro was arrested without a warrant in July 2002 after police discovered the body of a man hanging from a bedsheet in the shower of a room he had rented at Evaleigh Court, in Durban’s Point area.
Okoro rented the room two days before the discovery.
He remained in custody until 29 November 2002, when the murder charges against him were withdrawn. He subsequently instituted a damages claim of R5 414 000 against the Minister of Police, alleging that his arrest and detention were unlawful.
However, the KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban dismissed his claim with costs, finding that the arresting officers had reasonable grounds to suspect him of murder.
Following unsuccessful attempts to appeal the decision, Okoro approached the SCA President for reconsideration of the refusal to grant him leave to appeal.
In a judgment handed down this month, the SCA majority, comprising Acting Judge of Appeal Molitsoane and Judge of Appeal Nicholls, found that Okoro had failed to meet the legal threshold required for reconsideration of the earlier decision.
The majority held that the circumstances surrounding the discovery of the body, together with Okoro’s connection to the room and the observations made by the arresting officer, provided reasonable grounds for his arrest.
The court said that police officers do not need proof beyond reasonable doubt before making an arrest, but must have reasonable grounds to suspect that a person has committed an offence.
The judges also found no evidence that police had misled prosecutors or withheld important information to ensure Okoro remained in custody after his first court appearance in July 2002.
The court considered conflicting medical evidence concerning the death. A state pathologist found that the post-mortem results were consistent with suicide, although murder could not be ruled out. A second pathologist, commissioned by the deceased’s family, considered homicide more likely.
However, Acting Judge of Appeal Mjali disagreed with the majority, arguing that police had failed to establish sufficient grounds linking Okoro to the murder.
Mjali pointed out that two other people had access to the room and that police had not made sufficient efforts to locate them.
The judge also questioned discrepancies in the officers’ accounts of Okoro’s movements before the discovery, noting that he had appeared distressed and had himself directed police to the body.
Mjali would have granted Okoro leave to appeal and held the Minister of Police liable for proven damages arising from his arrest and detention.
The judges also differed over the legal threshold for reconsidering a refused appeal. Mjali held that the court should assess whether the proposed appeal had reasonable prospects of success, while the majority found that Okoro had to establish exceptional circumstances justifying the reopening of the matter.
The court also raised concerns about the lengthy delay in finalising the matter. Although the incident occurred in July 2002, the trial only commenced on 19 October 2020, more than 18 years later.
Molitsoane described the delay as unacceptable, warning that such prolonged proceedings could undermine public confidence in the justice system and prejudice litigants.
The SCA struck Okoro’s application for reconsideration off the roll with costs, including the costs of two counsel where employed.










