- SAWMU president Nkhetheni Muthavhi says failing municipalities are the result of political patronage and dysfunctional coalitions, warning that voters could deliver an even harsher verdict at the next local elections.
- “It may be a bloodbath at the next election if nothing changes.”
- In a blunt warning, SAWMU president Nkhetheni Muthavhi blames collapsing municipal services, corruption and unstable coalitions for growing voter anger and the ANC’s electoral decline.
By Amy Musgrave
South Africa’s largest municipal workers’ union, Sawmu, has blamed the country’s failing municipalities squarely on politicians and their inability to make coalition governments work.
Pulling no punches, Samwu president Nkhetheni Muthavhi warns that if political patronage continues in local government, the results of the next local polls will be even more dire for certain political parties.
Be the first to subscribe at discounted prices, click here
“How do I vote for a certain party that has been ruling when I don’t have water, when I don’t have roads, when there’s potholes everywhere, where corruption is thriving, where criminals have really taken over government?
“The message is very clear … the communities are sending a warning. It may be a bloodbath coming the next election if nothing changes,” he warns.
The ANC suffered its worst election setback since the first democratic polls in 1994. It only managed to secure 31% of the vote, with the public being frustrated over poor service delivery and around 30 million eligible voters staying away from the polls
Speaking during an interview on the Inside Metros podcast, Muthavhi said Samwu had not yet formulated a collective view on coalition governance.
Since the elections, the union had been part of meetings led by the Congress of SA Trade Unions with the SA Communist Party and the SA National Civic Organisation. They are all in a broad alliance with the ANC.
There have also been discussions with the Congress of Traditional Leaders of SA.
“I will take from the historical resolution that we have is that we are looking forward for having coalitions that will elevate service delivery above party politics. Forget about what you stand for. This is about coalitions. This is about service delivery.
“We must learn from other countries that have been in coalitions for long, countries such as Germany. You know, before they go into coalition, there must be agreement. This agreement must say … this is what we stand for…,” he said.
Be the first to subscribe at discounted prices, click here
Calls have intensified for coalition governments to publicly announce negotiated agreements, instead of just splitting portfolios amongst parties governing a municipality. But according to the Mapungubwe Institute for Strategic Reflection Coalition Barometer 2021–2023, formal agreements are the exception rather than the rule.
Muthavhi said such agreements needed to ensure that a municipality worked for everyone and did not become a “theatre of corruption, where people give each other tenders and they are not even delivering services to the people”.
He also spoke out against the chopping and changing in coalitions because of the instability this created in municipalities.
This is backed by extensive research, including in a report titled: Fiscal Sustainability in Coalition-Governed South African Municipalities: a Systematic Literature Review.
It warns that frequent changes in mayoral and executive leadership disrupt administrative continuity, leading to cadre deployment and policy paralysis.
There is also evidence of coalition infighting frequently delaying the tabling and approval of municipal budgets. This leads to non-credible financial planning and constrained municipal cash flows.
A new alliance
The outcome of the polls not only matter because they reflect growing public disillusionment with service delivery and voters using the ballot box to express their frustration, but also because they have effectively resulted in a reconfigured tripartite alliance.
The SACP secured 2.38% of the national vote in its first independent contest in the local government elections. Despite fierce objection from the ANC to the SACP going it alone, the party pressed ahead.
This comes after years of the SACP complaining about meetings that produce agreements but little implementation.
It will now be more difficult for the ANC to sideline it as a junior partner following its showing at the polls. The party will expect collective decision-making and meaningful influence over government policy.
Be the first to subscribe at discounted prices, click here
Muthavhi said that instability in the ANC, Cosatu or the SACP was bound to have an impact on the alliance, with meetings fraught with accusations of factionalism when participants stood for a certain position.
He described the SACP contesting the polls and its performance as a “divine intervention”.
“We could have not even had an option when it comes to who else do we go through, but it has brought a better realignment in the election system. [The SACP] is also in a good position to force changes to happen in their (communities where they won wards) lives. They must not fold their arms,” Muthavhi said.
He said the ANC needed to do some serious introspection.
“You know, we have to treat each other as equals. Don’t find yourself in the big brother mentality or syndrome. Don’t think 2.3% is bad. Yes, it’s something. And don’t take it as a by the way.
“Yes, there was a statement that was said by the ANC that says the party (SACP) does not bring anything to us when we go to elections … it’s now time that you talk about how to reconfigure [the alliance],” he said.
Muthavhi warned that if there was no realignment, it may spell the end of tripartite alliance.
The ANC and the SACP met on Monday to discuss governance stability and accountability in the interest of people, and not to create elite pacts during coalition talks. No alliance meetings have been scheduled since the election.
___________________________
Amy Musgrave is the Opinion and Analysis Editor for Inside Politics.










