- Advertisement -spot_img

Court orders Carrim and lawyers to contact Madlanga Commission over bail condition

- Advertisement -spot_img

Must read

By Johnathan Paoli

The Pretoria Magistrates’ Court has amended Suliman Carrim’s bail conditions, ordering the businessman and his legal team to contact the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry to arrange his next appearance before the commission, but without imposing a strict deadline.

Delivering his ruling on Friday, Magistrate Marc Curlewis said the amended condition should clarify the obligation without forcing a date for Carrim’s return to the commission, particularly as the inquiry still required him to respond to outstanding notices before deciding on his next appearance.

ALSO READ: Mashatile tells Parliament Zuma visited India to pray for SA ahead of local elections

“The accused and his legal representative are ordered to make contact with Dr Nolita Vukuza and/or the attorneys from the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry in order to make the necessary arrangements for the accused’s next appearance before the commission,” he ruled.

Curlewis said the wording was intended to reflect the original purpose of the bail condition, which was to ensure that contact was made with the commission to arrange Carrim’s appearance.

He said the commission’s position, as outlined in the statement by its secretary, was that a date could not be determined until Carrim had complied with outstanding Regulation 10(6) notices.

“I believe the defence has already entered into that process,” Curlewis said.

He said that he believed the process had been followed and that the commission’s own position was that a date could not be set until the notices had been answered.

The Pretoria Magistrates’ Court has amended Suliman Carrim’s bail conditions.

The amended condition replaced the previous wording, which required Carrim’s legal representative to report in person to the commission within 48 hours.

The State had brought the application under Section 63(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act, arguing that the original condition was unclear and ineffective because it placed the obligation on Carrim’s lawyer alone.

Prosecutor Donald Shiko argued that the condition needed to be amended to ensure that both Carrim and his legal representative were required to engage with the commission.

“The state is of the belief, Your Worship, that the condition was done obscurely and it placed the burden on the legal representative to make an arrangement,” Shiko said.

The State wanted the condition to expressly require Carrim and his lawyer to report to the commission’s secretary, Dr Nolita Vukuza, and its legal representatives within 48 hours to arrange his next appearance.

Shiko disputed the defence’s argument that the bail condition was unlawful, saying the charge against Carrim related to his failure to appear before the commission and did not concern the merits of what transpired during the inquiry.

He also argued that the condition had previously been accepted by the defence when bail was granted.

ALSO READ: Kubayi warns against migration misinformation as government steps up enforcement

The defence, however, opposed the amendment, arguing that the condition was legally problematic and that Carrim had already complied with its purpose through correspondence and subsequent engagements with the commission.

Defence attorney Ulrich Roux said Carrim’s legal team had emailed the commission’s secretary on 29 October, the day after bail was granted, attaching the court’s judgment and drawing attention to the condition.

Roux said the commission’s spokesperson issued a statement the following day alleging non-compliance before the defence had received formal correspondence from the commission’s attorneys.

“Our instructions, Your Worship, and my instructions are that that press release was maliciously issued, with the sole intent of causing harm to the accused and causing confusion, which it then did,” Roux said.

The defence argued that subsequent correspondence and an in-person meeting on 2 November between Carrim’s legal representatives and the commission’s attorneys demonstrated that the condition had been complied with.

Roux further argued that the amended condition risked compelling Carrim to appear before the commission before he had been found guilty of the offence he was accused of committing.

He said the commission had its own procedures, including Regulation 10(6) notices requiring witnesses to provide information and supporting documentation, before deciding whether to subpoena them.

ALSO READ: Madlanga grills JMPD’s Rikhotso over alleged R800,000 bribery of Hawks investigators

The defence maintained that the bail condition was ultra vires and should not be used to circumvent those procedures or prejudge Carrim’s criminal case.

Roux also challenged the commission’s interpretation of the original bail condition, arguing that the obligation to report had been placed on a third party who was not before the court.

He said the commission could not determine whether Carrim had breached his bail conditions, arguing that such a finding could only be made by a competent court after hearing evidence.

The State disputed that it had conceded the original condition was unlawful, saying it had merely argued that the wording was obscure and required clarification.

Carrim is facing a charge under the Commissions Act relating to his alleged failure to attend the Madlanga Commission.

The commission had previously heard his testimony on 9 and 10 March, but maintained that outstanding information and supporting documentation remain unresolved.

The commission issued Regulation 10(6) notices on 8 and 20 May requiring Carrim to provide further information arising from his testimony.

The commission has maintained that he must complete those responses before arrangements can be made for him to return and conclude his evidence.

The matter was postponed to 8 December for disclosure, with Curlewis confirming that Carrim had paid bail in the contempt case but remained in custody in another matter.

The amended bail condition will remain in place while Carrim and his legal representatives continue engaging with the commission over the outstanding notices and his eventual return to testify.

INSIDE POLITICS

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Inside Education E-edition August 2026

spot_img

Services Seta 2026

spot_img

CATHSSETTA

spot_img

AVBOB STEP 12

spot_img

Inside Metros G20 COJ Edition

spot_img

JOZI MY JOZI

spot_img

QCTO

spot_img

Latest article